With spring training just over a month away, the New York Yankees face significant questions regarding their 2025 roster. Chief among them is the infield alignment, particularly Jazz Chisholm’s role. After joining the Yankees at last year’s trade deadline, Chisholm played third base despite being a natural second baseman. According to Jack Curry of YES Network, the Yankees are inclined to return Chisholm to second base, leaving a gap at third base.

Infield options in flux

If Jazz Chisholm transitions back to his original position, the Yankees must address third base. Initial hopes of signing Alex Bregman dwindled due to his $200 million contract demands, and trade rumors surrounding Nolan Arenado have been dismissed. As it stands, the Yankees might depend on DJ LeMahieu’s resurgence or Oswald Peraza stepping into a larger role. While Oswaldo Cabrera offers versatility, he is better suited for a utility role.

This infield uncertainty adds pressure on the Yankees to avoid a lineup hole. Chisholm, projected to earn $6.7 million in arbitration, remains under team control through 2026, providing some stability. However, resolving the infield question is crucial as the team looks to rebound in 2025.

Strength in pitching

While the infield remains unsettled, the Yankees’ pitching staff appears formidable. Following the departure of Juan Soto to the Mets, New York shifted its focus to bolstering the rotation. The signing of Max Fried for eight years and $218 million creates a dynamic duo with Gerrit Cole at the top. The rotation also includes 2024 AL Rookie of the Year Luis Gil and veteran Carlos Rodon, who combined for a stellar 31-16 record last season. This depth positions the Yankees among the league’s best rotations.

However, the pitching surplus raises questions about Marcus Stroman’s future. Stroman, who joined the Yankees last year on a two-year, $37 million deal, was sidelined during the playoffs. Despite a respectable 10-9 record, his performance declined after August 1, posting a 6.15 ERA. Rumors suggest Stroman could be traded, potentially back to the Toronto Blue Jays, who might offer prospects in return.

The Yankees’ success in 2025 hinges on balancing their infield lineup and maximizing their pitching assets. The team’s Plan B approach—centered on run suppression rather than offensive production—relies heavily on its rotation. Whether the Yankees can fill the gaps at third base and make strategic roster moves like a Stroman trade will significantly impact their postseason aspirations.