The couple welcomed their fourth daughter together, baby Finnley Anne, earlier this week

Jason Kelce’s newborn daughter Finnley. Photo: Kylie (McDevitt) Kelce/Instagram; Stephen Lovekin/Shutterstock

Jason Kelce is already showing his newest little one his trademark sense of humor.

On Tuesday, April 1, Kylie Kelce, 33, announced that she and her retired NFL player husband, 37, welcomed their fourth daughter, Finnley “Finn” Anne. The proud mom shared a few photos of her little girl on Instagram, which included a close-up shot of the baby wrapped in a white blanket and wearing a pink hat with a blue bow.

In the comments, Jason joked with his wife, writing, “Does that first photo have a filter on it?”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer​​, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.  

Travis Kelce Meets Brother Jason’s Newborn Baby Girl, Learns Her Unusual Name and Gives Her a Sweet Nickname of His Own

Alongside baby Finn, the couple is also parents to daughters Bennett, 2, Elliotte, 4, and Wyatt, 5.

In November, Kylie and Jason first announced that they were expecting their fourth baby, another daughter, in an Instagram post.

“I feel like we captured a very accurate representation of how each of the girls feel about getting another sister,” a pregnant Kylie wrote in the Instagram caption. “At least Ellie, mom and dad are on the same page! ”

In the adorable snapshot, each Kelce girl donned matching sweaters with “big sister” embroidered on them.

The three girls showed a range of emotions, with Wyatt looking in disbelief as she cupped her hands to her head, Elliotte smiling wide for the camera, and Bennett crying.

On a March episode of her podcast Not Gonna Lie, Kylie shared that she had been making preparations for birth as she got ready to welcome her fourth daughter. The then-mom of three started by revealing that her labor was “imminent.”

“Before I get into this, as always, I just wanna say do whatever works for you. These are my personal preferences,” Kylie shared. “I’m not you and you’re not me, and we do not have to be living with each other’s decisions.”

She went on to explain what a birth plan is, calling it “basically all the things that you plan to do during labor.” Kylie said these can include doing a home birth, having a kiddie pool in your living room and being unmedicated, among other things.

“Now I’ll tell you exactly what my birth plan is,” she said. “That’s right. It’s mine. You don’t need to have an opinion on it. You don’t need to be worried about it because I’m gonna tell you this birth plan has been approved by me, myself and my team of OBs. Okay?”

“I just want a fat needle in my back. That’s it,” Kylie shared, referring to an epidural. “I want a fat needle in my back that keeps the line in so that when I need a little bumpity bump to get that window gone — if you know, you know — that we can make that happen.”