In a game where the stakes were high, Justin Tucker’s performance against the Philadelphia Eagles became a hot topic across the NFL landscape. The Baltimore Ravens faced a tough 24-19 loss, and it was a game to forget for Tucker, the esteemed kicker who has built a legacy over his illustrious career.

Having been named an All-Pro eight times, Tucker is undoubtedly one of the finest kickers to have graced the NFL. However, Sunday’s outing was strikingly uncharacteristic. Tucker missed two crucial field goals and an extra point — misfires that matched or exceeded his miss count from several entire seasons in his past, including 2012, 2013, 2016, 2017, 2019, and 2021, as noted by ESPN’s Bill Barnwell.

At 35, Tucker’s 2024 season has been a struggle, turning heads and raising eyebrows throughout the sport. With a current stat line of 19 successful field goals out of 27 attempts and 42-of-44 on extra points, his field goal percentage has plummeted to 70.4.

For context, Tucker’s previous low was 82.5% in 2015. It’s a downturn that has led many to ask the difficult question – is it time for the Ravens to consider moving on?

The conversation isn’t just limited to analytics; it’s resonating with fans and commentators alike. The dialogue around Tucker’s future is lively, with voices from all corners of the sports world chiming in about the once-unstoppable kicker now struggling to maintain his hallmark consistency. Social media lit up with commentary, some suggesting he should retire and others contemplating his place in the Ravens’ lineup in pursuit of a Super Bowl run.

It’s a compelling narrative, the idea of moving on from someone so integral to the Ravens’ identity. But given the Ravens’ aspirations, every missed opportunity in the kicking game is critical, especially as they look toward the playoffs. Coach John Harbaugh faces a potential decision that—while dramatic—may ultimately make sense in pursuit of championship glory.

Despite Sunday’s distressing performance and the overshadowing questions about his future, Tucker’s contributions to the Ravens—and the game—remain undiminished in the eyes of many. Whether he manages to rebound from this slump or the Ravens decide on a new direction, Tucker’s legacy as one of the greatest remains intact, though the current season serves as a challenging chapter in what has otherwise been a storied career.